
| home | forum | features | reviews | interviews | events | best-of | links | gallery | whoweare |
|
criticaldance.com ballet and modern dance forum
![]() Ballet
![]() American Ballet Theatre 2002 Spring/Summer Season (Page 3)
|
| This topic is 3 pages long: 1 2 3 | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
| Author | Topic: American Ballet Theatre 2002 Spring/Summer Season |
|
nancy Moderator |
Wow, Kate! Thanks so much for the reviews. One of my adult students went to last night's performance and saw Ananiashvili with Bocca, I believe, and Carreno as Ali. She was still gasping this morning and said all the dancing was sensational. In addition to the obvious, she praised the dancing of the children in the dream scene and said they looked very well rehearsed. Any thoughts, and do you know where they were from (SAB?) or who coached them? IP: Logged |
|
ksneds Member |
Hi! According to someone who posted on BalletTalk, ABT holds an open call when they need children for a production. Many of the kids are from SAB, but others are from other studios like STEPS in NYC. There's no mention as to who coaches the kids, which seems strange because NYCB always gives credit to the children's balletmaster or mistress in their program. I would assume the task is given to one of the balletmasters or company teachers. It's interesting to read about other casts of Le Corsaire, because I've only seen two casts, and only Corella as Ali. While I'm sure the other casts have been great, I really think that Corella & Acosta had the ultimate performance Monday night. I think it would be very hard for other dancers to follow up after such a night, but while Stiefel seems to have wilted a bit under the pressure, it's great to hear that Carreno and Bocca have thrived. IP: Logged |
|
Stuart Sweeney Administrator |
Revitalized by Ashton, A.B.T.’s Dancers Shine by Robert Gottlieb in The New York Observer
IP: Logged |
|
Basheva Moderator |
I don't know that I would agree with the term "Crankotrash" - but this is a very interesting article. And, while I might not agree with the term "Crankotrash" I do admire a critic who is not afraid to say which emperor he thinks has no clothes. I always did love Ashton. I have pictures of Seymour and Gable dancing Two Pigeons, but have never seen the ballet and would love to. IP: Logged |
|
nancy Moderator |
Gottlieb is... refreshingly honest... I don't agree about Crankotrash either, especially when used to describe "Onegin." I really did enjoy "La Fille Mal Gardee." The mime passage he mentions was especially touching and beautifully conveyed by Ananiashvili. And Acosta didn't hurt the production at all... ABT's production was grander than I remember the Royal's being. But the Royal's fit the simple country scene better and fit the stage at Covent Garden. It would have looked sparse at the Met, so the new production is appropriate, I think. As much as I liked this ballet, I wonder if the appeal would have been as great if 9/11 hadn't happened. We seem to be craving the simple things in life more than same time last year. Just a thought... I agree that Stiefel was great in "Dream." There was something ferocious and powerful in his portrayal of Oberon. He really wanted to possess Titania. I love Balanchine's "Dream" as well, and the contrasts between the productions were very interesting to me. Wish I had time to elaborate. Maybe later. IP: Logged |
|
Katydid Member |
Yeah, the use of the term "Crankotrash" almost made me skip the article ("Taming of the Shrew" is one of my favorite ballets). But you're right, Basheva, he does raise some interesting points. IP: Logged |
|
Stuart Sweeney Administrator |
Oldest surviving ballet story dusted off By Frederick M. Winship for UPI
The ballet's original production premiered in Bordeaux in 1789, the year of the French Revolution. In line with the Revolution's anti-elitist sentiments, choreographer Jean Dauberval turned his back on the gods and goddesses of classical ballet to create a realistic comic ballet about peasants danced to popular folk tunes. Dauberval's work had its American premiere in Philadelphia in 1794 and New York in 1828. Over the years it was re-staged by at least a half dozen choreographers including Bronislava Nijinska,, sister of legendary Russian ballet star Vaslav Nijinsky, and it was her version that was first danced by American Ballet Theater in 1940, its debut season. IP: Logged |
|
nancy Moderator |
I saw "Le Corsaire" on Saturday evening. The casting was much the same as what Kate saw on her second viewing. The performance was outstanding fun, but not with the excitement on the level Kate experienced when she saw Acosta, Herrera and Corella. Ethan Stiefel definitely went for the comic approach; he was camp and cartoony. First there was his ridiculous, long BLACK mustache to match his blond hair. He turned in a good performance, at times extremely undisciplined, but in this role, he gets away with it. Technically he is very strong, but he looks somehow light-weight in comparison to what's going on around him. (I feel so unfair even saying this when Ethan is such an accomplished dancer.) Corella turned in a nearly flawless portrayal of Ali the slave. I've seen him in this role before, and his dancing was superb, but here his characterization was so good that he commanded even when he was standing still. His second act variation was the best I've ever seen (live), with over-the-top virtuosity never outweighing his characterization. Joaquin de Luz is a small jack-in-the-box who pulled off eight pirouettes as if he were born turning. Both of his pistols fired on Saturday night. The Odalisques were fine indeed. Karin Ellis-Wentz filled in for Maria Riccetto and did a good job with her brisés, even if she did not look too happy or self-assured about them. Michele Wiles is all length and flexibility and strength. I feel she still needs some time to pull it together with artistry, and that the arms and upper body need some work. But the promise is there. And then there was Gillian Murphy in top form. Her diagonal of pirouettes was frightening: eight turns, I believe, alternating triples and quadruples. I don't usually count, but I wanted to be able to report accurately... Half way through I looked at her face to see if she was "buckling" or losing concentration. Sometimes you can see them thinking, "OK, do I have the energy to keep this up?" Not a hint here. Utter focus and composure. The rest of her variation was equally strong. In the midst of all this technical wizardry was Julie Kent. She is not of this generation, but her radiant elegance and maturity served as the calm center of the storm around which all this energy swirled. She did pull off the 32 fouettés, but you could see her working hard on technical matters. I didn't care. It was a pleasure to watch her. Xiomara Reyes did a very fine job with the role of Gulnare. Her acting was great -- I could feel her horror and confusion as she was sold to the Pasha as part of his harem. Her dancing was lovely, her piqué turns were as Kate described. She reminds me in some ways of Cheryl Yeager in that she is pert and petite. Last year I did not understand what the fuss was about and why she was getting bit parts in everything. Here I could understand and I look forward to watching her development in this company. Also noteworthy was Ethan Brown as the greedy, lecherous, bumbling Pasha. The dancers seem to have settled into this production after a few years, and they are finding new ways to add nuance, details and fun to it. It is a feast of a production. IP: Logged |
|
Misa_danseuse Moderator |
Jennifer Dunning writes in the NY Times:
quote: IP: Logged |
|
ksneds Member |
Hi! In re: Stiefel vs Acosta...one reviewer this ABT season(whose name escapes me) was talking about the differences between Stiefel and Carreno in File Mal Gardee. He/She pointed out that while Stiefel came across as a "randy" youth, Carreno was a man in love. This is how I see the difference in the interpretation of the role of "Conrad"-Acosta has a huge, mature stage presence, whereas Stiefel's slender, blond looks and in-cheek acting makes the role very youthful and lightweight. And I think that Acosta's more serious, intense interpretation matches better with the intensity that Corella devotes to his role. I also was entranced by Corella's ability to command attention even when not dancing. He spends a good deal of the first act onstage, and he never seems to get out of character-and it makes the 2nd act all the more magical to have this slight, seemingly somber dancer come to life in a fantastic display of pyrotechnics. IP: Logged |
|
Misa_danseuse Moderator |
Jennifer Dunning writes in the NY Times:
quote: IP: Logged |
|
Misa_danseuse Moderator |
Jack Anderson (NY Times) reviews two different casts in Giselle:
quote: ...And another Jack Anderson article on Giselle:
quote: IP: Logged |
|
Misa_danseuse Moderator |
Anna Kisselgoff writes in the NY Times:
quote: IP: Logged |
|
Misa_danseuse Moderator |
Anna Kisselgoff writes in the NY Times:
quote: IP: Logged |
|
Azlan Administrator |
In the Village Voice:
quote: More, in the third item of the linked article IP: Logged |
|
nancy Moderator |
I had read Kisselgoff's review before seeing Kent and Corella last night in "Swan Lake." I agree with her on one point -- perhaps Julie was having a bad day on Wed. Whatever qualms Kisselgoff had about her, I had very few complaints about last night's performance. We are used to Swans where it is really Odette/Odile's show. Thanks to the strength of the men at ABT and probably to McKenzie's staging, there is more opportunity to shift the balance in favor of Siegfried. Last night I felt the partnership was just about perfect. Julie, while technically not quite so amazing as the current generation, turns in a strong performance with beautiful line, and she has come into her own as an actress. I'll grant Kisselgoff that, at moments, the acting seems to be superimposed on the dancing, but only at moments. I found Kent's a very moving, convincing Odette/Odile. Corella has always been a joy to watch. He seems to have matured this year; his characterizations are richer, more textured than in the past. He looks more mature, he relates more fully to his partner. His command of the stage and of his technique are extraordinary. He is a treasure. Another noteworthy performance was that of Marcelo Gomes as Von Rothbart in his human incarnation. I'd gone in bemoaning the fact that I was not seeing Malakhov in the role; last year he was outstandingly, seductively evil in it. But in a very different, all-powerful interpretation, Gomes was...I begin to run out of adjectives for these men...stupefying. Throw in Joaquin de Luz lighting up the Pas de Trois, and Herman Cornejo with Craig Salstein in the Neapolitan Dance, and it was an amazing night. And I must not forget the appearance of Frederic Franklin as Wolfgang. On the women's side, in addition to Julie's fine performance, Xiomara Reyes looked very good in the Pas de Trois, as did Stella Abrera in both the Spanish Dance and as a Big Swan. The corps looked good most of the time, with only a few ragged edges. But it's been a long run... Flowers flew through the sky, for everyone including the corps. All in all, a wonderful performance to end a wonderful season. Look out West Coast -- here they come! And we'll have the Kirov here to help me with my end-of-season "withdrawal." I'm looking forward to their Swan. IP: Logged |
|
Glebb Member |
I saw Wiles' first 'Corsaire'. She's a very nice dancer though I think I might like to see her in a year or so when she is more coached and experienced. However, the dancing of the soloist women and men was great. Corps was good too! McKerrow's (possibly last)'Giselle' was beautiful. She looked like a young Ulanova. Very beautiful but not a lot of balon, which 'Giselle' should really have. Stiefel was a powerhouse of an Albrecht. He was an aristocrat who could not really hide it. I was not thrilled with the corps, nor the soloists in Act II. In the past the Queen of the Wilis was most often danced by a principle dancer and I was expecting that level of technique and artistry. Joaquin De Luz was fantastic in the Peasant Pas. What clean beats and high elevation and endless pirouettes. 'Swan Lake' - Ananiashvili and Bocca were greeted as superstars and they are superstars! She is completely glamorous and his technique is so easy and clean. I wish she would not hold her foot so crossed at her knee when she turns, but she is a beautiful artist and the queen of the dance these days. Herman Cornejo shined in the pas de trois from Act I. His double cabrioles are the best I have ever seen. So high and such space between the beats. He is another fantastic turner. Just keeps turning with ease and in such a perfect position. I'm not crazy about Kevin McKenzie's choreography for 'Swan Lake'. The old David Blair production was much better, though the sets and costumes for the new production do look like a million and a half. Best performance for me was Gillian Murphy as Odette/Odile. Her dazzling technique (triple fouettes) and her new level of artistry have earned her the status of my favorite dancer. She is so young, I can only imagine how amazing she will be in a year or two. Carreno was charismatic and clean. A prince of the dance. This year's ABT is very different from the ABT of last year. The company is looking much more well rehearsed and the level of talent is on par with the great companies of the world. ABT might even be the best in the world. IP: Logged |
|
nancy Moderator |
Glebb, I did not see any of the performances you did, but from what I did see of Wiles, I agree with you. The potential is there but perhaps they are just rushing her a bit? Who did you see as Myrtha in "Giselle"? You mention it was not a principal dancer. Kisselgoff commented on the over-crossed foot at the knee that seems to be in vogue in turns (I don't think it was with reference to Ananiashvili; actually I think she was complimenting one of the men for NOT doing it). She didn't like it either. I think I agree with you in general about Mc Kenzie's choreography for "Swan Lake." The first act seems busy to me, but not with purpose. In concept, I'm still having trouble with the aristocrats and peasants celebrating together in the first act. I do like the dual, expanded role for Von Rothbart. That's concept, though. For actual choreography, I preferred the old version of Act IV. And the character dances are about a draw for me, but I do like this Neapolitan Dance. And I agree with you about the sets and costumes (except maybe for the shorts on the peasant men...). I can imagine what Gillian Murphy's Odile was like. How was her Odette? I can't compare with other great companies because I haven't seen any recently enough. But this was a season apart for ABT. There were certainly many world class moments and performances.
IP: Logged |
|
Glebb Member |
Crossed leg is now in vogue for pirouettes? I can't imagine!!!!! The Queen of the Wilis I saw was Stella Abrera. She's very pretty and I liked her solo in Act I of 'Corsaire', but I did not find her up to the demands of Myrtha. No one equals Makarova in control, but Murphy was a very good Odette. In time she will be a great Odette. I have a lot of problems with McKenzie's 'Swan Lake'. It's weird for the Queen to have no court in Act I. She has the two ladies in waiting who carry the gift for her son, but they leave and then the Queen leaves alone. She should have ladies in waiting, guards and pages for her train etc. Why is there a tutor? In this version he is just decoration. No realtionship with the Prince, no tipsy dance with a peasant girl and no almost skipping off with the peasants at the end. I miss that. As for the Neapolitan Dance, I enjoy it and the little turning competition, but why do all the other countries have men and women and the Neapolitans only have men? Act IV is the worst. What do the random exits of the swans mean? There are two beautiful pieces of music traditionally used that are gone. [This message has been edited by Glebb (edited July 08, 2002).] IP: Logged |
|
Misa_danseuse Moderator |
Jack Anderson writes in the NY Times:
quote: [This message has been edited by Misa_danseuse (edited July 09, 2002).] IP: Logged |
|
Misa_danseuse Moderator |
Anna Kisselgoff writes in the NY Times:
quote: IP: Logged |
| This topic is 3 pages long: 1 2 3 All times are PT (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
|
Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Version 5.39c
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 1999.